Are You at Fault if Someone Pulls Out in Front of You?

It’s a split-second moment: you’re driving through Edmonton when suddenly, another car pulls out in front of you. You slam on the brakes, but there’s not enough time—and a collision follows. Now you’re left asking, are you at fault if someone pulls out in front of you?

The answer isn’t always simple.

In Alberta, fault in car accidents is determined using a comparative fault system. That means fault can be shared—or assigned entirely to one party—depending on the specific facts of the crash. Just because someone pulled out in front of you doesn’t automatically mean you’re not at fault. But in many cases, the driver who entered your path will bear most or all of the blame.If you’ve been injured in a crash like this, an experienced Edmonton car accident lawyer can help you understand your rights, protect you from unfair blame, and fight for the compensation you may deserve.

GET YOUR FREE CONSULTATION NOW!

How Right-of-Way Works in Alberta

To determine who’s at fault, Alberta law starts with right-of-way rules. These rules govern who must yield when two vehicles approach an intersection, merge point, or other traffic scenario.

In most “pull-out” crashes, one vehicle is:

• Turning left across traffic
• Merging from a side street or private driveway
• Exiting a parking lot or alley
• Entering an uncontrolled intersection

Under Alberta’s Use of Highway and Rules of the Road Regulation, drivers must yield to oncoming traffic when turning left, and must not enter a roadway unless it’s safe to do so. If another driver cuts into your lane and causes a crash, they likely violated your right of way.

However, fault isn’t determined solely by who had the right of way. The law also considers how each driver behaved before the crash—speed, distraction, weather conditions, and reaction time can all influence the final outcome.

That’s why working with an Edmonton car accident lawyer is so important. They can review the facts, apply the correct legal standards, and make sure your side of the story is heard.

Situations Where You May Still Be Partially at Fault

Even when someone pulls out in front of you, Alberta’s contributory negligence laws allow fault to be shared if your actions contributed to the crash.

You might still be assigned partial fault if you were:

• Speeding – If you were driving over the speed limit, even slightly, the other driver’s insurer may argue you would’ve avoided the crash at a lower speed.
• Distracted – Looking at your phone, adjusting music, or eating could lead to fault being shared—even if you had the right of way.
• Driving impaired or fatigued – Reduced reaction time or judgment may shift some responsibility to you.
• Following too closely or accelerating unnecessarily – Even if the other driver pulled out, insurers may argue you should have been more cautious or had time to brake.

In Alberta, your compensation is reduced by the percentage of fault assigned to you. For example, if you’re found 25% at fault, your payout is reduced by 25%.

That’s why it’s critical to gather evidence that clearly shows your driving was safe and legal. An experienced Edmonton car accident lawyer can fight to reduce or eliminate unfair fault assignments and preserve the value of your claim.

What to Do Immediately After a Crash Where Someone Pulled Out in Front of You

What you do in the moments after a crash can help protect your health—and your legal rights.

Here are the steps to take:

1. Call 911 immediately. Even in minor crashes, call the police. A written report can clarify fault later.
2. Seek medical attention. Some injuries take hours or days to show. Visit a doctor promptly and follow all instructions.
3. Take photos of everything. Capture the damage to both vehicles, road markings, signage, and anything that might show how the crash occurred.
4. Get witness information. If anyone saw the crash, ask for their name and contact details.
5. Don’t admit fault. Avoid saying “sorry” or “I didn’t see them.” Even casual comments can be used against you.
6. Contact an Edmonton car accident lawyer. The sooner you speak with a lawyer, the faster they can begin preserving evidence, handling insurance adjusters, and protecting your claim.

Why “Pull-Out” Crashes Are So Common in Edmonton

Many drivers assume that urban collisions only happen at high speeds or during bad weather—but “pull-out” accidents are among the most frequent types of crashes in Edmonton.

Common scenarios include:

• A driver exiting a residential street onto a major roadway without properly yielding
• Someone pulling out of a parking lot or gas station and misjudging traffic
• A left-turning driver crossing a busy intersection during yellow or red lights
• A motorist entering from a private driveway or alleyway with limited visibility

In these cases, the driver pulling out must wait until it is safe to proceed. Unfortunately, impatience or inattention often leads to serious collisions—especially when the through-driver is traveling at a consistent and legal speed.

These types of crashes can happen at any time, but are especially common during:

• Rush hour traffic
• Nighttime or poor lighting conditions
• Icy or wet roads where traction is reduced
• Near schools or construction zones

Understanding how and where these collisions occur can help strengthen your claim—and explain why you should not automatically be blamed.

Why Fault Is Not Always Clear at the Scene

After a crash, emotions run high. It’s natural to feel shaken or even guilty—but fault is a legal determination, not a matter of who apologizes first or speaks the loudest at the scene.

In many cases, the driver who pulled out will claim they “didn’t see you,” or try to argue that you were speeding or not paying attention. Meanwhile, insurers may try to split fault 50/50 to reduce their payout.

Here’s why it’s important not to jump to conclusions:

• The other driver may be in shock or lying to protect themselves
• Witnesses may have only seen part of the event
• Road conditions or signage may have contributed
• Dashcam or video footage may reveal the truth later

Even if you’re confident that you weren’t at fault, saying the wrong thing at the scene could give the other side leverage. Let a qualified Edmonton car accident lawyer evaluate the evidence before assumptions turn into legal liabilities.

Alberta’s Contributory Negligence Rule: A Quick Primer

Alberta follows a contributory negligence model. That means multiple parties can share fault, and your compensation is reduced by your percentage of fault.

For example:

• If the other driver is found 80% at fault, and you are 20% at fault, your compensation is reduced by 20%.
• If you’re 0% at fault, you may be entitled to full compensation.
• If you’re found over 50% at fault, your recovery may be limited significantly.

This rule is often used by insurers to blame innocent drivers, especially in cases with unclear or conflicting evidence. That’s why it’s so important to have a lawyer who understands Alberta traffic law and can challenge unfair fault assignments.

How Fault Impacts the Value of Your Injury Claim

Fault isn’t just about who’s blamed—it affects how much money you receive.

If someone pulled out in front of you and caused the crash, proving they were 100% at fault can help you recover compensation for:

• Pain and suffering
• Lost income and future earnings
• Vehicle repair or replacement
• Rehabilitation and long-term care needs
• Psychological trauma and emotional distress

However, if fault is split—even slightly—it can reduce your payout by thousands of dollars.

Don’t let the other driver or their insurance company downplay their actions. An experienced Edmonton car accident lawyer can ensure your injuries and losses are fully valued and not minimized by shared fault tactics.

How Alberta Insurance Companies Investigate Fault in Pull-Out Crashes

After a collision, you might expect the insurance companies to make a fair, fact-based decision. But in reality, insurers often look for ways to minimize payouts—even if that means blaming the wrong driver.

Here’s how most insurance companies investigate fault:

1. Review of driver statements – Both drivers provide written or recorded versions of what happened. Inconsistencies can affect fault decisions.
2. Police report analysis – Citations, diagrams, and officer observations can carry weight but may not be final.
3. Photos of the crash scene – Vehicle positions, road debris, and impact zones help reconstruct events.
4. Vehicle damage evaluation – The location and severity of the damage can suggest which vehicle moved into the other’s path.
5. Witness statements – Independent witnesses often help establish right-of-way violations or confirm reckless behaviour.
6. Dashcam or surveillance footage – If available, video evidence can strongly influence the outcome.

Unfortunately, insurers often default to splitting fault—even when one driver clearly pulled out without yielding. They may claim you were “too fast,” “not paying attention,” or had “enough time to stop.” This tactic reduces what they have to pay out.

If you’re facing an unfair decision, speak with an Edmonton car accident lawyer who can challenge the insurer’s findings and submit stronger evidence on your behalf.

Why Legal Representation Matters in Disputed Fault Crashes

When another driver pulls out in front of you, the facts may seem obvious—but that doesn’t mean the insurance process will be fair. In many cases, your version of events is directly challenged, and the insurer pushes for a compromise that doesn’t reflect what really happened.

Hiring a lawyer can make a major difference. Here’s how legal representation helps:

• Preserving crucial evidence like video, scene measurements, and vehicle data
• Investigating beyond the police report, including independent expert opinions
• Communicating directly with insurers so you don’t have to
• Challenging fault assessments based on improper assumptions or weak analysis
• Protecting your claim’s value and ensuring all damages—physical, emotional, and financial—are fully documented and pursued

If you were injured in a crash and someone pulled out in front of you, a skilled Edmonton car accident lawyer will make sure your rights are defended every step of the way.

How MNH Injury Lawyers Can Help You After a Pull-Out Collision

At MNH Injury Lawyers, we understand how frustrating it is to be injured because someone else acted carelessly—only to be treated unfairly by their insurer. We’ve helped countless clients in Edmonton navigate complex “pull-out” crashes where fault was disputed, unclear, or wrongly assigned.

When you work with us, we:

• Conduct a thorough investigation into how the crash occurred
• Request and preserve dashcam, video, and black box evidence
• Work with accident reconstruction experts when needed
• Handle all communication with the insurance company
• Fight for compensation that reflects the true impact of your injuries

You focus on recovery. We focus on results.

Unsure If You’re at Fault After a Pull-Out Crash? Call MNH Injury Lawyers Today

So, are you at fault if someone pulls out in front of you? In most cases, the answer is no—but Alberta’s insurance companies don’t always get it right. Even if fault seems obvious, you may still need legal guidance to ensure your rights are protected.

If you’ve been injured in a collision like this in Edmonton, you may be entitled to compensation for:

• Pain and suffering
• Lost wages and future income
• Medical and rehabilitation costs
• Emotional distress
• Damage to your vehicle or property

At MNH Injury Lawyers, we’re here to help. There’s no cost to speak with us—and no legal fees unless we recover compensation for you.Call (888) 664-5298 today to speak with an experienced Edmonton personal injury lawyer. Your recovery starts with answers, and we’re ready to provide them.

GET YOUR FREE CONSULTATION NOW!