Every driver owes you a duty to watch the road, yield when required, and make safe choices around pedestrians. When a driver ignores those rules and hits you, evidence is your leverage to hold them accountable.
You deserve clear answers, a solid path forward, and a team that knows Alberta’s process inside and out. If you want someone on your side who puts your story first—whether you need a Calgary Pedestrian Accident Lawyer or help with another injury claim—call MNH Injury Lawyers at (888) 664-5298 today.
GET YOUR FREE CONSULTATION NOW!
Burden of Proof & Standard
Alberta uses the “balance of probabilities” standard. That means you only need to tip the scale slightly in your favor. You (and your lawyer) don’t need to prove guilt beyond a shadow of a doubt, as in criminal cases. You need enough evidence to show it’s more likely than not that the driver acted negligently.
That standard gives you power. You don’t need perfect proof. You just need enough to convince the insurer or a judge that you deserve compensation.
Evidence You Can Control Right Now
Medical Trail
Start with your medical records. Each appointment, test, and prescription forms a paper trail that ties your injuries to the crash.
- ER Visit Notes: The emergency room chart shows what doctors saw and how they treated you. If they suspect concussion, a CT scan or MRI result proves it.
- Specialist Referrals: If a neurologist or orthopedist diagnosed a spinal-cord issue or fracture, that diagnosis moves your case beyond a simple strain.
- Physiotherapy & Rehab Reports: Every session note reveals ongoing pain, limited range of motion, or delayed healing. That counters insurers who say “it’s just a minor sprain.”
- Pain Journal: Write down daily pain levels, medication dosage, and flare-ups. Your journal shows that your pain exceeds what a typical soft-tissue injury causes.
- Medication Logs: List each prescription, dosage, and refill. If you need stronger pain medication weeks after the crash, you have proof that your injuries run deep.
Paper & Digital Footprint
After you’re home, secure every document related to the collision.
- Police Collision Report: This report gives you a collision diagram, officer notes, and witness information. Order it immediately—some jurisdictions purge reports after a few months.
- Driver’s Exchange: Keep the sheet where you exchanged names, license numbers, and insurance details. That identifies the insurer you must notify.
- Insurance Correspondence: Save every email, letter, or recorded phone summary. Insurers sometimes send settlement offers or requests for recorded statements. Preserve these to avoid surprises.
- Ticket Status: If the driver received a ticket for speeding or failing to yield, that ticket helps prove breach. If the officer declined charges, note that too; your lawyer will need to show why their decision doesn’t erase the driver’s negligence.
- Witness List & Statements: If someone saw the crash, record their name and contact info. Write down their version of events before memory fades. That snapshot often outperforms a wet signature weeks later.
Photos, Video & Tech
Visual evidence transcends “he said, she said.” Collect anything that captures the scene.
- Smartphone Photos: If you snapped pictures of skid marks, vehicle damage, or road conditions right after the accident, keep those files safe. They document exactly what you saw.
- Dash-Cam & Security Cameras: Many drivers don’t disable their dash-cams for weeks. Reach out to nearby businesses or homeowners to preserve store or home-camera footage. If they refuse, a preservation letter from a lawyer forces production.
- City CCTV: Municipal cameras often record intersections. The sooner you get legal counsel on your side, the sooner they can request footage—municipal archives loop quickly.
- Smartwatch & Phone Data: Your phone’s location history and your watch’s heart-rate spike at the crash moment create an objective timestamp. That data shows you walked at a normal pace until the exact second you hit the pavement.
- Environmental Factors: If the light was green for the driver, note the timing cycle. If rain made the road slick, track weather records. Each detail reinforces how conditions impacted the crash.
Personal Diary & Lifestyle Impact
Insurers want numbers. You can show them, beyond medical bills or lost pay, what the crash cost you.
- Daily Routine Logs: Record tasks you once handled—driving your kids to school, walking your dog, grocery shopping—and how your injuries forced someone else to pick up the slack.
- Work Impact Notes: If you missed shifts, track each missed hour. If a promoter canceled your event appearance, list that lost opportunity. Attach emails or pay stubs to show exact figures.
- Hobbies & Activities: You used to go to the gym three times a week. Now you struggle to sit for more than 30 minutes. Note each cancelled class or dropped membership.
- Emotional Strain: If you once led an active life and now lie awake each night battling headaches, jot it down. That journal entry later helps support your pain-and-suffering claim beyond what Swift claims allow.
- Family Testimonials: If your spouse ends up doing yard work or cooking because your back locked up, ask them to write a paragraph. A neighbor’s note on how you fall asleep on the couch most nights creates context. Those stories matter when insurers only see numbers on a spreadsheet.
Professional Evidence that Closes the Loop
Accident-Reconstruction Engineers
Accident-reconstruction engineers examine skid marks, vehicle crush damage, and scene measurements. They use laser scanners to map the road, calculate vehicle speed, and chart the point of impact. Their reports show whether the driver braked in time or took an evasive turn.
When you hire an engineer, they inspect the collision scene, measure distance between tire marks, and calculate reaction time. Those numbers speak louder than opinions. A reconstruction report ties the driver’s actions to physics. Insurers must face the cold math: if the car traveled 60 km/h in a 40 km/h zone and failed to brake before hitting you, the engineer’s findings remove any doubt about breach.
Biomechanics & Human-Factors Specialists
Biomechanics experts explain how an impact forces your body to move. They use video stills and medical data to show the moment your center of mass shifted and how your knee snapped under that energy. They break down the collision like a slow-motion replay.
A human-factors specialist steps in when the driver claims they never saw you. That specialist studies sight lines, sun angles, and driver reaction times. If you wore dark clothing at dusk, the specialist tests visibility at 10 and 50 meters. They calculate how long it takes for human eyes to detect a pedestrian’s silhouette against asphalt.
Those expert opinions dismantle claims that “it was too dark” or “I never saw them.” When you pair reconstruction numbers with biomechanics commentary, you build a case that no insurer can ignore.
Vocational & Economic Analysts
When injuries stop you from returning to work, vocational analysts estimate your future earning capacity. They review your job duties, education level, and projected career path. If you worked in construction before the accident and now you can’t lift more than 10 kg, a vocational assessment shows you lost your trade skill.
Economic analysts turn that assessment into a dollar figure. They project your lost wages, adjust for inflation, and calculate pension impacts. If you planned a promotion or income boost, those future projections go into your claim. Insurers often downplay long-term loss. A solid economic report forces them to account for your full financial setback, not just the weeks you missed on the job.
Key Alberta Statutes & Insurance Rules That Shape Proof
Alberta Insurance Act
The Alberta Insurance Act mandates that insurers investigate every claim in good faith. It requires them to disclose policy details, report on decisions, and explain denials. Section 7 of the act forces insurers to respond to your claim within a strict timeline. If they delay or give vague reasons, your lawyer uses that violation to pressure a quick settlement.
The act also contains statutory conditions that influence fault. For example, you must notify the insurer of the driver’s identity within seven days. Missing that window gives insurers a reason to deny liability. When you follow every step under the act, you close off any procedural loopholes insurers might exploit.
Standard Automobile Policy (SPF No. 1)
Section A (Liability Coverage) compensates third parties when a policyholder injures or damages someone else. Section A sets out the insurer’s duty to defend and indemnify if the driver caused your injury. When you build evidence under Section A, you prove breach and causation.
Section B (Accident Benefits) provides no-fault coverage for medical and rehabilitation expenses, up to specified limits. You submit treatment receipts, physiotherapy bills, and income-loss records directly to your own insurer. Section B pays those costs regardless of who caused the crash. That payment record creates a paper trail you later use under Section A to show how severe your injuries ran. Accepting Section B benefits does not undermine your negligence claim. It simply ensures you get treatment and income support while you gather fault evidence.
Minor Injury Regulation Cap
Alberta’s Minor Injury Regulation (MIR) limits pain-and-suffering awards for strains and sprains to a fixed cap—currently $6,061. If your diagnosis shows only soft-tissue damage, insurers cling to that cap. You need objective medical proof that your injury goes beyond a minor sprain.
- Diagnostic Imaging: If an MRI reveals a disc bulge or a partial tendon tear, you move outside the MIR.
- Specialist Reports: An orthopedist’s opinion that your neck pain stems from a cervical herniation voids the cap.
- Persistent Symptoms: When doctors note that pain lasts months longer than normal in a typical soft-tissue case, that chronic record pierces the MIR boundary.
When you aim to exceed the MIR, you push for tests, referrals, and expert opinions within weeks of the crash.
Common Defence Tactics—and Evidence That Counters Them
Contributory Negligence Allegations
Insurers argue you share blame if you jaywalked or crossed outside a crosswalk. They might claim you wore earbuds or distracted yourself. Your lawyer prepares for this by gathering evidence that shows you crossed legally and remained visible.
- Traffic Signal Data: If a pedestrian signal gave you a “walk” sign, legal counsel can retrieve the intersection’s timing record.
- Witness Statements: A passerby might confirm you waited for cars to stop before stepping off the curb.
- Visibility Tests: A human-factors specialist recreates the scene at the same time of day to confirm you stood in plain view.
When you pair those details, you prove you did not contribute to the crash. The insurer’s attempt to reduce your award falls apart.
Minor Injury Argument by Insurers
Insurers push the idea that “everyone heals from a sprain in six weeks.” They send lowball offers under the MIR cap. To defeat that tactic, your lawyer lines up objective proof that your injury exceeds a simple strain.
- MRI & X-Ray Results: Show ligament tears, herniated discs, or fractured cartilage.
- Specialist Referrals: When a surgeon schedules you for microdiscectomy, you prove the injury severity.
- Physio Progress Reports: A physiotherapist’s notes show slow healing and persistent weakness.
With that proof, insurers must negotiate far above the MIR limit.
Unavoidable Accident Claim
When drivers say “it was an unavoidable accident,” they imply they had no time or space to avoid you. You push back using reconstruction reports and speed calculations.
- Engine Control Module Data: A mechanic downloads the car’s black-box data to show throttle and brake actions.
- Skid-Marks Analysis: An engineer calculates braking distance and proves the driver could have slowed down.
- Weather & Road Conditions: If the road felt slick, pull weather records. But combine that with skid-mark evidence to show brakes engaged too late.
When you put precise numbers against the driver’s claim, “unavoidable” becomes “avoidable.”
Soft-Tissue Injuries
Insurers label most strains and sprains as “minor.” You fight that label by capturing a detailed timeline of your symptoms.
- Early Physiotherapy Notes: Shows whether your progress lagged behind typical healing curves.
- Chronic Pain Assessments: Pain specialists assign you a scale rating each visit.
- Trigger-Point Injections: If you received injections into your neck or back, save those bills. They prove severe, persistent pain.
- Work-Restriction Letters: If your general practitioner limited your return to work, that note carries weight.
FAQ for “How Can I Prove Driver Negligence in a Pedestrian Accident Case?”
Your lawyer will send a written preservation notice citing Alberta’s rules on evidence spoliation. If the owner still resists, they will file a notice with the Court of Queen’s Bench requesting production. That forces the owner to submit footage or explain in open court why they can’t.
If you identify the driver, you file an uninsured motorist claim under your own Section A. If the driver fled, report the hit-and-run to police, obtain a collision report, and contact the Alberta Motor Vehicle Accident Claims Fund. That fund compensates victims when a driver cannot be found or lacks insurance.
Most pedestrian claims in Alberta settle because insurers weigh expert evidence against potential trial risks. If your proof—medical records, reconstruction, witness statements—paints a strong picture of negligence, insurers tend to settle early. But if they lowball you or deny liability without merit, MNH Injury Lawyers prepares a court filing without hesitation.
Yes. A smartwatch recording a sudden spike in heart rate at the crash moment and a drop in step count creates time-stamped, objective proof you experienced trauma. Combined with location data—showing you crossed legally—your wearable becomes a powerful piece of evidence.
Let MNH Fight for You
You deserve full recovery. A trusted Calgary personal injury lawyer can take on the burden of gathering evidence, building a case, and facing insurers—so it’s not something extra to deal with while you’re hurting.
MNH Injury Lawyers takes that burden off your shoulders. We transform every receipt, report, and expert opinion into a winning strategy.
Call (888) 664-5298 now. Let MNH fight for you and turn your proof into the justice you deserve.
